Guides from the shop
Title Insurance and Title Search in Lake and Porter County, Indiana

Before you close on a house, a title company searches the public records to confirm the seller can sell it and to find any liens or other claims. Title insurance then covers you against certain problems that started before you bought, like a past owner’s unpaid taxes or a contractor who says the work was never paid for. Your lender will usually require a lender’s policy. The owner’s policy is usually your choice. Indiana adds a $5 state fee to each title insurance policy you buy. This is general information, not legal advice.
We’re the shop at 112 S. Main St., Suite B, Crown Point, and we help buyers and sellers across Northwest Indiana and Chicagoland. Love Thy Neighbor. Call Sash at (219) 808-1520 or Pam at (219) 801-0432.
Search homes on Realest.com
Call Sash at (219) 808-1520
Sash walks through the difference between an owner’s title policy and a lender’s policy on a Lake or Porter County home.
What the title search looks for
The Indiana Department of Insurance describes the search as a detailed look at the public records on the property: deeds, court records, property and name indexes, and other public documents (IDOI, what is a title search). The point is to confirm the seller has the right to transfer the house and to turn up anything that clouds the title. A good search should show:
- Unpaid property taxes
- Mortgages that were never released
- Judgments against the seller
- Liens and land use restrictions
The department also points out that the seller’s old title policy doesn’t protect you as the buyer. A problem could have started while the seller owned the house, and a new policy is what covers your ownership. The results usually come to you as a title commitment before closing. Real Estate USA explains what a title commitment is and how to read one.
Defects and encumbrances
A title defect is a problem in the title that cuts into your ownership. The department lists errors or gaps in the public records, forgery, mix ups over similar names, fraud, and wrong marital status, and gives the example of an heir of a past owner who turns up and claims the land (IDOI, what is a title defect).
An encumbrance is a claim on the land by someone other than the owner. A utility easement for power lines is a common one and is often fine. Other encumbrances may not be. If you’re borrowing, your lender will want clear title before it approves the loan.
Owner’s policy and lender’s policy
There are two policies, and they protect different people. The lender’s policy covers the loan. Its coverage shrinks as you pay the mortgage down and ends when the loan is paid off. The owner’s policy is usually written for the full value of the house and lasts as long as you or your heirs own it. You pay for it once, at closing, with no monthly premium (IDOI, why buy title insurance).
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says the lender’s policy doesn’t protect your equity, and if someone brings a claim against your home, you’re the first one responsible (CFPB, lender’s title insurance). It also notes that buying both policies from the same provider usually costs less in total than buying them separately (CFPB, owner’s title insurance).
Under either policy, the insurer pays covered losses up to the face amount and pays the legal costs to defend covered claims (IDOI, what does it cover). Read the exclusions and exceptions. The department’s list includes:
- A title defect you knew about that wasn’t recorded
- Building and zoning violations
- Restrictive covenants that limit how you use the property
- Boundary line conflicts, shortages in area, and encroachments
- Claims tied to water rights when the property is on or near a lake, river, or stream
- Claims by renters or others in possession of part of the property
If your next home sits near a flood zone or on the water, our flood zones page covers what to check before you write an offer.
Who picks the title company, and who pays
When the buyer uses a federally related mortgage loan, federal law says the seller can’t require the buyer to buy title insurance from any particular title company as a condition of the sale. A seller who does can owe the buyer three times all the title insurance charges (12 U.S.C. 2608). The Indiana Department of Insurance adds that you don’t have to use the title company your agent or lender recommends, though your lender can turn down your choice (IDOI, shopping tips).
Who pays each premium isn’t set by Indiana law. The department says local practice decides it and buyers and sellers can negotiate. Your purchase agreement spells out which side pays for each policy. The department also says to ask about simultaneous issue rates when one insurer writes both policies, and about refinance and first time buyer discounts.
On your Loan Estimate, title service fees show up on page 2 in section B or C. Section C means you can shop for them. An owner’s policy, if you buy one, is listed in section H (CFPB, title service fees). Real Estate USA walks through what a Closing Disclosure is line by line. We don’t quote premiums here. Those numbers belong to the title company on your statement.
The $5 Indiana fee
Indiana Code 27-7-3.6-7 says a person who buys a title insurance policy pays the insurer a $5 fee for the title insurance enforcement fund when paying for the policy. The insurer keeps $2 and sends $3 to the Indiana Department of Insurance (IC 27-7-3.6). The fund pays for title insurance investigations and enforcement and for consumer education about residential title insurance.
Bringing money to closing
Indiana’s good funds law tells the closing agent which money it can pay out (IC 27-7-3.7). Good funds include cash, a wire, and a cashier’s or certified check. A personal check counts only up to $500 per closing. If the money from one party adds up to $10,000 or more, all of it has to be good funds and anything over $10,000 has to arrive by wire. A check written on a licensed real estate broker’s trust account can also count, under conditions in the statute. Real Estate USA covers what earnest money is.
Before you send a wire, call the title company at a number you already have, not one from an email, and confirm the instructions.
The county side
In Lake County, deeds and mortgages are recorded with the Lake County Recorder, whose office is at 2293 N. Main Street in Crown Point. In Porter County, since January 2, 2024, the Porter County Auditor reviews every document presented for transfer before it’s accepted. Papers filed in person need at least 72 business hours for that review (Porter County Auditor, deeds).
For a Porter County deed to get through, the auditor looks for the correct names of the sellers and how they hold title, a valid legal description, notarized signatures from every seller, and where future tax bills should go. Sellers, those are the same details the title company will ask you to confirm early.
If a problem shows up after closing
Contact the title insurer named on your owner’s policy as soon as you find a problem, and have the policy number ready. The department says to make the claim in writing, include copies of anything related, and keep copies for yourself (IDOI, how to make a claim). The Indiana Department of Insurance regulates title insurers and title agencies, and you can file a complaint with it if you think one acted improperly.
Towns we work in
In Lake County we help buyers and sellers in Crown Point, Hammond, Gary, Hobart, Merrillville, Munster, Highland, Dyer, Schererville, St. John, and Cedar Lake. In Porter County we work in towns including Valparaiso, Portage, and Chesterton. The state rules on this page apply in every one of them.
Before closing
- Read the title commitment when it arrives and ask about anything listed against the property.
- Decide whether you want an owner’s policy, and ask for the simultaneous issue rate.
- Check which side the purchase agreement charges for each policy.
- Find the title lines on page 2 of your Loan Estimate.
- Ask the title company how it wants your money, and plan a wire for anything over $10,000.
- Keep your owner’s policy with your deed after closing.
Our buyer closing costs page and seller closing costs page cover the rest of the statement. Our property tax due dates page explains the bills a search checks for, and the Indiana seller’s disclosure page covers what sellers have to tell buyers. Start with our buying guide or selling guide. Buying across the state line? See our Illinois guide, and Real Estate USA compares Indiana and Illinois closing costs and title. Search homes on Realest.com.
Questions buyers and sellers ask
What does title insurance cover in Indiana?
It pays on covered claims against your ownership that started before you took title, such as errors in the public records, forgery, a previous owner's unpaid taxes, or a contractor who says the work was never paid for. The Indiana Department of Insurance says a policy pays covered losses up to its face amount and pays the legal cost to defend covered claims. Every policy also lists exclusions and exceptions, so read yours.
Do I have to buy an owner title policy in Lake or Porter County?
Usually not. Most lenders require a lender's policy, and the Indiana Department of Insurance says an owner's policy is usually optional. The lender's policy protects only the loan. An owner's policy protects your own stake in the house, is paid once at closing, and lasts as long as you or your heirs own the property.
Who pays for title insurance in Indiana?
No Indiana law sets it. The Indiana Department of Insurance says local practice, not the law, decides who pays the premiums, and buyers and sellers can negotiate them. Your purchase agreement says which side pays for each policy, and the amounts show up on your Closing Disclosure or settlement statement.
Can the seller make me use a certain title company?
Not when you buy with a federally related mortgage loan. Federal law, 12 U.S.C. 2608, says the seller cannot require you to buy title insurance from any particular title company as a condition of the sale, and a seller who does can owe you three times the title insurance charges. The Indiana Department of Insurance adds that you do not have to use the title company your agent or lender recommends, though your lender can turn down your choice.
What is the $5 title insurance fee in Indiana?
Indiana Code 27-7-3.6-7 says a person who buys a title insurance policy pays the insurer a $5 fee for the title insurance enforcement fund when paying for the policy. The insurer keeps $2 and sends $3 to the Indiana Department of Insurance, which uses the fund for title insurance enforcement and consumer education.
Can I bring a personal check to closing in Indiana?
Only a small one. Under Indiana Code 27-7-3.7-4, a personal check counts as good funds only up to $500 per closing. Cash, a wire, or a cashier's or certified check counts. If the money you bring adds up to $10,000 or more, section 7 says anything over $10,000 has to arrive by wire. Ask your title company how it wants the money before closing day.
Sources
- What is title, Indiana Department of Insurance
- What is a title search, Indiana Department of Insurance
- What is a title defect, Indiana Department of Insurance
- Why buy title insurance, Indiana Department of Insurance
- What does title insurance cover, Indiana Department of Insurance
- Title insurance shopping tips, Indiana Department of Insurance
- How to make a title insurance claim, Indiana Department of Insurance
- Indiana Code 27-7-3.6, title insurance enforcement fund
- Indiana Code 27-7-3.7, escrow transactions and good funds
- 12 U.S.C. 2608, title companies and liability of seller
- What is owner’s title insurance, CFPB
- What is lender’s title insurance, CFPB
- What are title service fees, CFPB
- Fees for services, Lake County Recorder
- Deeds, plats and subdivisions, Porter County Auditor
Buying or selling? Call the shop and we’ll walk you through the title steps on your house.
Search homes on Realest.com
Contact the shop
Call Sash at (219) 808-1520
Call Pam at (219) 801-0432
